A 5‑year‑old girl was referred from routine school medical services after a heart murmur was detected.
❓ Q1. Describe the radiographic findings. What is the most likely diagnosis?
✅ Model Answer:
• Cardiomegaly (cardiothoracic ratio >50%).
• Left ventricular enlargement – apex displaced downwards and to the left.
• Left atrial enlargement – convex left atrial border.
• Increased pulmonary vascularity – prominent pulmonary arteries (pulmonary plethora).
• Vascular markings extending to the lung periphery.
• Diagnosis: Ventricular septal defect (VSD).
❓ Q2. What are the classic physical examination findings in a child with VSD?
✅ Model Answer:
• Loud, harsh holosystolic murmur at the left lower sternal border (LLSB).
• Palpable thrill – often present at the LLSB in small/restrictive VSDs.
• Loud P2 – if pulmonary hypertension is present (large VSD).
• Widely split S2 – may be present if associated with pulmonary hypertension.
• Apical diastolic rumble – due to increased flow across the mitral valve (large VSD with left-to-right shunt).
• Murmur intensity inversely correlates with defect size: Small VSD = loud murmur; large VSD = softer murmur.
❓ Q3. What is the significance of murmur intensity in VSD? Why do small VSDs have loud murmurs?
✅ Model Answer:
• Murmur intensity is inversely related to the size of the VSD.
• Small VSD: High pressure gradient across the defect → high-velocity turbulent jet → loud harsh holosystolic murmur with palpable thrill.
• Large VSD: Low pressure gradient (equalization of ventricular pressures) → lower velocity flow → softer murmur, often without thrill.
• Clinical pearl: A loud murmur with thrill in an asymptomatic child suggests a small, restrictive VSD. A soft murmur with signs of heart failure suggests a large VSD.
❓ Q4. What are the different types of VSD? Which is the most common?
✅ Model Answer:
• Perimembranous (membranous) VSD – most common type (80%). Located in the membranous septum, near the tricuspid valve and aortic valve. High risk of aortic regurgitation.
• Muscular VSD – 5-20%. Located in the muscular septum. High rate of spontaneous closure (80%).
• Inlet (AV canal) VSD – 5%. Located near the AV valves. Associated with Down syndrome.
• Outlet (supracristal) VSD – 5%. Located below the pulmonary valve. Associated with aortic regurgitation.
❓ Q5. What is the natural history of VSD? Which types are most likely to close spontaneously?
✅ Model Answer:
• Spontaneous closure:
- Muscular VSD: 80% close spontaneously (often in the first 2 years of life).
- Perimembranous VSD: 30-50% close spontaneously (may close in childhood).
- Inlet and outlet VSDs: rarely close spontaneously.
• Natural history of small VSD: Asymptomatic, normal growth, no significant hemodynamic effect. Excellent prognosis.
• Natural history of large VSD: Heart failure (at 2-6 weeks of life), failure to thrive, pulmonary hypertension. May progress to Eisenmenger syndrome if untreated.
• Eisenmenger syndrome: Reversal of shunt (right-to-left) due to severe pulmonary hypertension → cyanosis, clubbing.
❓ Q6. A 3-month-old infant with VSD presents with tachypnoea, tachycardia, and poor weight gain. What is the most likely diagnosis and management?
✅ Model Answer:
• This is heart failure due to a large VSD.
• Timing: Heart failure typically presents at 2-6 weeks of life (when pulmonary vascular resistance drops).
• Management:
1. Medical management: Diuretics (furosemide), afterload reduction (captopril), and nutritional support (high-calorie feeds).
2. Surgical closure: If medical management fails to control symptoms, surgical VSD closure (patch closure) is indicated.
3. Timing of surgery: Usually performed at 3-6 months of age (or earlier if symptoms are severe).
4. Pulmonary artery banding: Rarely used now – reserved for multiple VSDs or complicated cases.
❓ Q7. What is Eisenmenger syndrome? How does it present in VSD?
✅ Model Answer:
• Eisenmenger syndrome: Reversal of left-to-right shunt to right-to-left due to severe, irreversible pulmonary hypertension.
• Pathophysiology: Long-standing left-to-right shunt → pulmonary vascular remodeling → increased pulmonary vascular resistance → reversed shunt.
• Clinical features:
- Cyanosis (central), clubbing.
- Murmur changes: Holosystolic murmur becomes softer, P2 becomes loud and palpable.
- Dyspnoea, fatigue, syncope, hemoptysis.
- Polycythemia (secondary to chronic hypoxia).
• Management: VSD closure is contraindicated (high mortality). Treatment is supportive (pulmonary vasodilators, oxygen, phlebotomy for polycythemia). Heart-lung transplant may be considered.
❓ Q8. What is the role of echocardiography in VSD? What parameters are assessed?
✅ Model Answer:
• Echocardiography is the gold standard for diagnosis and assessment of VSD.
• Assessed parameters:
1. Size and location of the VSD (perimembranous, muscular, inlet, outlet).
2. Shunt direction and magnitude (left-to-right vs right-to-left).
3. Pressure gradient across the VSD – estimates the degree of restriction.
4. Ventricular chamber size – LV and LA enlargement indicates a significant shunt.
5. Pulmonary artery pressure – estimated from tricuspid regurgitation velocity.
6. Associated lesions – aortic regurgitation (perimembranous VSD), pulmonary stenosis, subaortic stenosis.
7. Ventricular function – LV function, RV function.
❓ Q9. A 5-year-old with a small VSD and a loud murmur is asymptomatic with normal CXR. What is the management?
✅ Model Answer:
• This is a small, restrictive VSD.
• Management: Observation.
• Follow-up: Regular cardiology follow-up with echocardiography every 1-2 years.
• Indications for closure:
- Development of symptoms (heart failure, exercise intolerance).
- Evidence of significant left-to-right shunt (LV/LA enlargement).
- Development of aortic regurgitation (perimembranous VSD).
- Endocarditis prophylaxis is not recommended for isolated VSD.
- Spontaneous closure is likely (especially if muscular or small perimembranous).
❓ Q10. What are the indications for surgical closure of VSD?
✅ Model Answer:
• Indications for surgical VSD closure:
1. Heart failure refractory to medical therapy (large VSD).
2. Pulmonary hypertension – evidence of elevated PA pressure (to prevent Eisenmenger syndrome).
3. Significant left-to-right shunt – Qp:Qs > 2:1 with LV/LA enlargement.
4. Aortic regurgitation – due to prolapse of the aortic valve (perimembranous VSD).
5. Failure to thrive – poor weight gain despite medical management.
6. Inlet VSD – associated with AV valve regurgitation.
7. Multiple VSDs – if they cause symptoms.
8. Transcatheter device closure – for selected muscular VSDs.
❓ Q11. A child with a perimembranous VSD develops a new diastolic murmur. What is the most likely complication?
✅ Model Answer:
• Aortic regurgitation – due to prolapse of the aortic valve cusp into the VSD.
• Mechanism: The VSD is located near the aortic valve; the Venturi effect can cause prolapse of the right coronary cusp into the defect, leading to aortic regurgitation.
• Clinical features: Diastolic murmur at the left upper sternal border (aortic regurgitation) + holosystolic murmur (VSD).
• Management: Surgical closure of the VSD with aortic valve repair/replacement.
• This is an indication for surgical closure even in small VSDs.
❓ Q12. What is the risk of infective endocarditis in VSD? Do patients need prophylaxis?
✅ Model Answer:
• Risk: VSD is a moderate-risk lesion for infective endocarditis (especially if associated with aortic regurgitation).
• Prophylaxis: According to 2007 AHA guidelines, endocarditis prophylaxis is NOT recommended for isolated VSD.
• Exception: Prophylaxis is recommended for patients with a repaired VSD with a residual shunt (patch or device) or VSD with aortic regurgitation.
• Good dental hygiene is important to reduce the risk of endocarditis.
⚠️ Key concept: A loud, harsh holosystolic murmur at LLSB with a thrill in an asymptomatic child is classic for a small or moderate ventricular septal defect (VSD).
The loudness of the murmur inversely correlates with defect size – a small defect has a high pressure gradient → loud murmur.
📋 Mock Test Feedback
💡 Examiner's note: Compare your answers with the model answers. In real TOACS, you would discuss these with the examiner.